- Top Pick: Lenovo Legion Go S (Ryzen Z2 Go, 16GB, 512GB)
- Runner-up: ASUS ROG Xbox Ally (Ryzen Z2 A, 16GB, 512GB)
- Also consider: SanDisk 1TB Extreme microSDXC Card
This is the cross-tier question in today’s handheld market: ASUS’s flagship ROG Xbox Ally X, built on AMD’s Ryzen AI Z2 Extreme, against Lenovo’s value play, the Legion Go S with its Ryzen Z2 Go. On a spec sheet the gap looks total, but emulation does not read spec sheets. Each console generation asks for something different, and below a certain generation both machines are simply fast enough. The useful question is where that line falls — and what the extra headroom buys above it.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
So this comparison judges both machines against the emulators’ own published tiers — PCSX2’s and RPCS3’s — rather than benchmark scores. Hardware figures come from ASUS’s specification pages and Lenovo’s PSREF sheet. Throughout, games and BIOS files mean dumps from your own discs, cartridges and consoles; nothing here points to download sources.
This article contains affiliate links, and we may earn a commission if you buy through them.
Quick Answer
For emulation, the ROG Xbox Ally X is the stronger machine: its Zen 5 chip runs PS2, GameCube and Wii at higher internal resolutions and takes PS3 and Xbox 360 emulation further, title by title. The Legion Go S plays the same cartridge-era, PS1 and PSP libraries just as well, on a bigger, sharper screen, and gives up ground only from the PS2 generation upward.
Two Chips, Two Bets
The Xbox Ally X pairs the Ryzen AI Z2 Extreme — eight Zen 5 cores, sixteen threads, up to 5.0GHz per ASUS’s specification — with RDNA 3.5 graphics, 24GB of LPDDR5X memory and a 1TB SSD. The Legion Go S answers with the Ryzen Z2 Go: four Zen 3 cores and eight threads up to 4.3GHz, RDNA 2 graphics and 16GB of memory. On paper, that is not a close fight.
Both machines run Windows 11, so the same standalone emulators — PCSX2, Dolphin, RPCS3, Xenia, RetroArch and the rest — install identically on each. The X boots into the Xbox full screen experience, full Windows desktop underneath; the Go S organises its library through Legion Space. One caution: the Go S shell also comes with a Z1 Extreme chip and in a SteamOS edition; this comparison covers the Windows Z2 Go model below.
Where They Tie: Cartridge Era to PSP
From the 8-bit and 16-bit libraries through the PlayStation and the PSP, both chips overshoot what the emulators ask for. DuckStation and PPSSPP demand far less than either processor offers, and RetroArch’s cartridge-era cores are lighter still. Here the contest stops being about the chip: image quality is decided by the screen, and session length by how gently these light loads treat the battery.
The screen point goes to the Go S: its 1200-line panel takes a 240-line console image at an exact 5x integer scale, as clean as retro scaling gets. The X’s 1080p panel cannot integer-scale the same image, though at 7 inches that is a purist’s concern rather than a visible flaw. On stored energy the X holds the advantage — 80Wh against 55.5Wh — and both sip power at loads this light. Verdict: a tie — the Go S is the rational buy if your library ends here.
Where the X Pulls Ahead: PS2, GameCube and Wii
PCSX2 publishes the ladder for this tier. Its Moderate tier asks for a PassMark single-thread rating of 2000, a G3D Mark of 6000 and 16GB of memory; its Heavy tier asks for 2600, 12000 and 8GB of VRAM — a figure written for desktop cards. The Z2 Go sits between the Minimum and Moderate tiers, which sets the Go S’s frame: the PS2 library at native resolution as the baseline, 2x per game where a title allows. The Z2 Extreme clears the Moderate tier’s processor and memory bars outright, and its graphics headroom buys what the Go S cannot promise: 2x to 3x internal resolutions across much of the library, the heaviest games still negotiated one by one.
Dolphin tells the same story for GameCube and Wii: both machines run the library, the X rendering at higher internal resolutions and downsampling to its panel, the Go S at native to 2x. HD texture packs sharpen the difference: they draw on the memory pool the system and GPU share, and 24GB against 16GB leaves the flagship more room before it squeezes. Cemu follows the pattern: same compatibility, more headroom.
PS3 and Xbox 360: Per-Title vs Light Titles Only
RPCS3’s published recommended tier describes a desktop: a six-core, twelve-thread processor, a Vulkan-capable AMD or NVIDIA graphics card and 16GB of memory. The Xbox Ally X matches that thread count on paper with its eight Zen 5 cores, but a handheld’s power limits are not a desktop’s, and RPCS3’s compatibility database is the real referee: around seven in ten tested games are rated Playable, while headline exclusives remain stuck at Ingame. The X’s honest verdict is per-title — check your games in the database first.
The Go S sits below that tier on core count alone: the lightest Playable titles, approached as experiments rather than a reason to buy. Xenia draws the same shape — more titles within reach on the X, only the lightest on the Go S. Neither machine replaces a desktop for this generation; the X simply fails later and less often.
Screen, Battery and the Weight Surprise
The panels pull in opposite directions. The Go S offers the bigger, sharper screen: 8 inches at 1920×1200, with a 48–120Hz variable refresh range that suits the odd refresh rates retro systems produce, 50Hz PAL libraries included. The X counters with a smaller 7-inch 1920×1080 panel at a fixed 120Hz with FreeSync Premium; ASUS rates its brightness at 500 nits. Docked to a TV, the panel argument disappears entirely.
Battery is stored energy, not a runtime promise: 80Wh against 55.5Wh is roughly half again as much in the tank, but the flagship’s chip can spend it faster at full tilt, so the visible gap depends on the power profile you run. The surprise is weight: ASUS lists the X at 715g, slightly lighter than the Go S at around 740g despite its larger battery. Lenovo spent its grams on the screen.
The Machines and Gear in This Comparison
One note before the products: the Xbox Ally X’s own Amazon listing could not be verified to the standard this comparison requires, so the X is covered in prose above rather than given a product slot. What follows is the Go S, the X’s labelled smaller sibling, and gear serving both.
Lenovo Legion Go S (Ryzen Z2 Go, 16GB, 512GB)
The value side of this comparison, and the rational pick for libraries ending at the PSP: a bigger, sharper, variable-refresh screen than the flagship’s, with enough chip for the PS2 generation at native-to-modest resolutions.
Specs:
- Processor: AMD Ryzen Z2 Go, 4 cores / 8 threads, up to 4.3GHz
- Memory: 16GB LPDDR5x-6400, soldered
- Storage: 512GB SSD, plus microSD expansion
- Display: 8-inch IPS, 1920×1200, 48–120Hz variable refresh rate
- Battery: 55.5Wh
- Operating system: Windows 11
- Weight: around 740g
ASUS ROG Xbox Ally (Ryzen Z2 A, 16GB, 512GB)
Not the X — this is its smaller sibling, listed so this comparison’s naming trap has a face. It shares the X’s Xbox full screen experience and 120Hz panel but runs a four-core Zen 2 chip, and belongs to an earlier comparison in this series.
Specs:
- Processor: AMD Ryzen Z2 A, 4 cores / 8 threads
- Memory: 16GB
- Storage: 512GB SSD
- Display: 7-inch IPS, 1920×1080, 120Hz, FreeSync Premium
- Battery: 60Wh
- Operating system: Windows 11
- Model: RC73YA
- Weight: around 670g
SanDisk 1TB Extreme microSDXC Card
Both handhelds keep a microSD reader, and a card this size carries a whole cartridge-era library with room for PS2 images besides — the easiest way to grow either library without opening the machine.
Specs:
- Capacity: 1TB
- Model: SDSQXAV-1T00-GN6MA
- Read speed: up to 190MB/s
- Write speed: up to 130MB/s
- Speed classes: C10, U3, V30, A2
Samsung T7 Portable SSD 1TB
The shuttle drive for a disc-image library: fast enough to move PS2, GameCube and PS3 images between a desktop and either handheld, and the natural home for a backup copy of your saves.
Specs:
- Capacity: 1TB
- Model: MU-PC1T0T/AM
- Interface: USB 3.2 Gen 2, up to 10Gbps
- Read speed: up to 1,050MB/s
- Write speed: up to 1,000MB/s
JSAUX 6-in-1 Docking Station HB0609
For TV play: one cable covers video, charging and wired networking. One caveat from the maker’s own listing: it does not pass through variable refresh rate, so the Go S’s VRR advantage stays on its own screen.
Specs:
- Model: HB0609
- Video: HDMI output up to 4K at 120Hz
- Charging: USB-C pass-through up to 100W
- Network: Gigabit Ethernet
- Data ports: USB-A and USB-C, USB 3.2 Gen 1
- Compatibility: Legion Go S, ROG Ally line, Steam Deck, per the maker
How to Choose
Start with the newest system in your library. If it stops at the PSP, buy the Go S and spend nothing on headroom you will never use — its screen is better for those systems anyway. If PS2, GameCube and Wii are the core of your library and you push internal resolutions and texture packs, the X’s chip and 24GB memory pool are the real article. If PS3 or Xbox 360 experiments are part of the plan, only the X is worth trying them on — title by title, never assumed. Screen-first buyers should weigh the Go S’s panel heavily; battery-first buyers, the X’s 80Wh.
Who Should Skip
Skip the Xbox Ally X if your library ends at the PS1 and PSP era: you would pay flagship money for capability those systems cannot use. Skip the Legion Go S if high-resolution PS2 and GameCube upscaling is the whole point of the purchase; its chip was not built for that and no setting changes it. Skip both if PS3 emulation is your primary goal: RPCS3’s recommended tier describes a desktop, and a desktop is what that needs. And skip any listing that blurs the Ally names: the 2024 ROG Ally X is a different, older machine.
FAQ
Is the ROG Xbox Ally X the same machine as the ROG Ally X?
No. The ROG Ally X is ASUS’s 2024 handheld on the Ryzen Z1 Extreme. The ROG Xbox Ally X, model RC73XA, is the later machine on the Ryzen AI Z2 Extreme, with the Xbox full screen experience over Windows 11. Similar names, different hardware — check the model code before ordering.
Can the Legion Go S actually run PS2 games?
Yes. Judged against PCSX2’s published tiers, its chip sits between the Minimum and Moderate tiers, which means most of the PS2 library at native internal resolution, rising to 2x on titles with headroom. The heaviest games are a per-game conversation.
Which screen is better for retro games?
For undocked retro play, the Go S’s panel has the stronger hand: an extra inch, more pixels, and a 48–120Hz variable refresh range that follows the rates older systems output. The X’s 120Hz FreeSync Premium panel is smooth and, per ASUS’s rating, bright — it gives up size and resolution to get there.
Final Verdict
The decision rule is a single question: how far past the PSP does your library go? The Legion Go S covers everything up to that line, on the better screen, and its chip deficit never shows. Past that line, the X earns its flagship tier in the only currency emulation accepts: higher internal resolutions in PCSX2 and Dolphin, room for texture packs, and a PS3 and Xbox 360 tier that is per-title instead of theoretical. Buy the Go S for the library you have; buy the X for the library you are still building.











